How to choose a keyboard (or not)

Keyboards are a key piece of equipment to consider when you are experiencing finger, hand, wrist, and arm pain.  But different keyboards are going to be better for different types of discomfort – and one is not necessarily better than the other.  Here is a review of three main types:

1. Split keyboards – These are keyboards that come in two pieces or have a large space between the middle of the keyboard effectively splitting the keyboard in two.  The biggest advantage of split keyboards is that they place the wrists in a neutral posture, rather than radial deviation with standard keyboards.  The disadvantage is that people find them to quite wide requiring them to raise their elbows slightly rather than keeping them close to their torso.  This increases muscle activation in the deltoid muscle and can cause fatigue in the shoulder.

2. Natural keyboards – These keyboards rest on the same premise as split keyboards with a more natural curve as opposed to a complete split.  These seem to be a good middle ground for alleviating wrist deviation while keeping the elbows down.  But studies have not shown that natural keyboards significantly reduce the chance of work-related injury.  And these keyboards usually come with a wrist/palm rest making it harder to reach the keys and increasing the risk for injuries caused by prolonged contact stress.

3. Non-numeric keyboards – These keyboards are made without a numeric keypad on the right side of the keyboard or the numeric keypad is on the left side of the keyboard.  These are my favourite keyboards of the bunch because they significantly reduce the reaching required when mousing.  Being able to eliminate 5-6 inches of reaching really makes a difference in all areas of the right arm.  Deltoid activation is reduced, weight on the palm/wrist is reduced, and elbows have a more neutral posture.

However, despite the wide array of keyboards available, the standard keyboard will suffice for most people.  More often than not, the most effective way to reduce hand/arm discomfort is to change your postures and working habits, not your keyboard.  Here are some tips:

1.      Adjust height of keyboard tray to ensure elbows are at 90 degrees of flexion (to eliminate the constant need for the neck and shoulder muscles to raise the arms)

2.      Ensure the keyboard tray is parallel to the ground or at a negative tilt (the back of keyboard is lower than the front).  The keyboard tray should not be tilted positively (the front of the keyboard is lower than the back).

3.      Ensure both keyboard and mouse are on the keyboard tray (to reduce shoulder and arm strain)

4.      Keep wrists neutral when keyboarding and mousing, i.e. keep wrists straight (to reduce wrist strain)

5.      Do not rest wrists on wrist rests while keyboarding.  Wrist rests are for resting wrists during pauses from keyboarding.  Consider removing wrist rest completely (to reduce wrist compression)

6.      Move your keyboard and mouse to very edge of keyboard tray closest to you so that your wrists are free floating and cannot rest on the tray (to eliminate wrist and forearm compression)

7.      Try to mouse with the right side of the palm resting on the mouse pad, not the inside of the wrist (to reduce wrist compression)

8.      Try to use your left hand for mousing (to give your right hand a break). To change your mouse to a left-handed mouse – go to Start, Control Panel, Mouse.

9.      Use keyboard keys to reduce mouse use and eliminate scrolling (to reduce strain placed on wrist extensor muscles):

§  Page Up and Page Down

§  Arrow keys – up and down

§  Ctrl+Home – straight to top

§  Ctrl+End – straight to bottom

§  Click Vertical Scroll Bar

§  Drag Vertical Scroll Bar

10.     Take breaks from keyboarding and/or mousing frequently (to give your body a break)

11.     Alternate tasks every 15-30 minutes throughout the day (to reduce prolonged exertion on one set of muscles)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s